Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattress Review

Based on Q&A session with our Chief Sleep Science Editor, www.SmartMattressBuy.com

Last updated | April 7, 2024

Smartmattressbuy.com provides objective and unbiased recommendations to help you find the best mattress for you. When you use our links to shop for products, we may earn a commission at no cost to you and in no way affects our editorial independence.

Click to View Model Options +
Brooklyn Bedding Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattress
Methodology

Methodology

We gather information on mattress industry, product, pricing, customer reviews and financial information from more than 50+ websites daily through our automated “bots” and use advanced data analytics techniques to evaluate and rate mattresses.

update

Updates

Our reviews are updated at least once a week in cases of changes, product releases, and new insights gathered from analyzing our data set.

Format
Format

We present our mattress reviews in a Q&A format with the intent of mirroring the thought process of how customers make mattress purchase decisions

Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattress

By Brand: Brooklyn Bedding
4.13 out of 5.0
$1332 $999
           


Product Description

Plank Firm by Brooklyn Bedding is an all-foam mattress that is designed to provide a firm and supportive sleep surface. It is made with four layers, 0.75-inch of quilted top and bottom, 1.5-inch layer of high-density foam, a 2-inch layer of memory foam, and a 6-inch layer of base foam. The high-density foam supports the body, while the memory foam conforms to the body to relieve pressure points. The base foam provides a firm foundation for the mattress.

Plank Firm mattress is available in two firmness levels: firm and extra firm. The firm side is ideal for people who prefer a firmer sleep surface, while the extra firm side is ideal for people who need extra support. It is a flippable, sustainable, and durable mattress. In a flippable mattress, you can choose the firmness level that best suits your needs.

Plank Firm mattress is made with CertiPUR-US certified foam and is free of harmful chemicals and materials. It is also covered by a 10-year warranty.

Q1. What is unique about the Brooklyn Plank Firm mattress? Does it provide superior cooling, comfort, back support, and pressure relief?

The Brooklyn Plank Firm mattress is unique in a few ways. First, it is a flippable mattress, which means that you can choose between a firm and an extra firm side. This is a great option for people who are not sure what firmness level they prefer, or for people who sleep with a partner with different firmness preferences.

Second, the Plank Firm mattress is made with CertiPUR-US certified foam, which means it is free of harmful chemicals and materials. This is important for people who are concerned about their health and safety.

Third, Plank Firm mattress is covered by a 10-year warranty. This is a long warranty, which shows that Brooklyn Bedding is confident in the quality of its product.

Plank Firm mattress provides good cooling, comfort, back support, and pressure relief. The memory foam relieves pressure points by conforming to the body, and the firmness of the mattress provides good back support. However, Plank Firm mattress is not as cooling as some other mattresses on the market. If you are a hot sleeper, you may want to consider a mattress with more cooling features.

Overall, Brooklyn Plank Firm mattress is a good option for people looking for a firm and supportive mattress. It is made with high-quality materials, is covered by a long warranty, and provides proper cooling, comfort, back support, and pressure relief.

 Q2. How firm is Brooklyn Plank Firm mattress?

Brooklyn Plank Firm mattress comes in two different firmness levels – firm and extra firm. On a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being the firmest, one side of Plank Firm mattress is 8, meanings it has a firm feel to it. The other side of the mattress is 10, meaning it is extra firm. The firmness level 10 makes Brooklyn Plank as one of the firmest mattresses in the market.

Plank Firm mattress is made with a combination of foams, including a high-density polyfoam base layer, a layer of memory foam, and a quilted top layer. The combination of these foams provides a lot of support and minimal motion transfer. This makes Plank Firm mattress a good choice for people who sleep with a partner or who toss and turn a lot during the night.

If you are looking for a very firm mattress that provides a lot of support, Brooklyn Plank Firm mattress may be a good option for you.

Q3. How thick is Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattress?

Brooklyn Plank is an all-foam mattress with a 10.25-inch thick profile. Sleepers can switch sides for the desired firmness level.

Q4. Is Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Mattress Safe?

Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm mattress is generally considered to be safe. It is made with CertiPUR-US certified foams, which means that they have been tested and meet certain safety standards. The mattress is also free of harmful chemicals and flame retardants.

Here are some additional safety tips for using Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm mattress:

  • Use a mattress protector to protect the mattress from spills and stains.
  • Rotate the mattress every few months to distribute wear and tear evenly.
  • If you experience any discomfort while sleeping on the mattress, stop using it and contact Brooklyn Bedding for assistance.

Q5. What sizes are available for Brooklyn Plank Firm mattresses?

Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattress comes in standard sizes – Full, Twin, Twin XL, King, Queen, California King, Split Cal King, Short, and RV.

Q6. Briefly discuss Brooklyn Bedding’s policy on shipping, delivery, risk-free trial, and warranty.

Brooklyn Bedding offers various policies to ensure a seamless shopping experience for customers. Here’s a brief overview of Brooklyn Bedding’s policies on shipping, delivery, risk-free trial, and warranty:

  • Shipping and Delivery: Brooklyn Bedding provides free shipping within the United States. They use FedEx for most of their deliveries, and the estimated delivery time may vary depending on the location. Orders are shipped in between 2 to 3 business days after purchase. Customers will receive a tracking number to monitor the progress of their delivery. The mattress gets delivered to your doorstep.
  • Risk-Free Trial: Brooklyn Bedding offers a generous 120-night risk-free trial period for their mattresses. This trial allows customers to sleep on the mattress in their own homes and determine if it meets their comfort needs. If the customer is not satisfied with the product within the trial period, they can initiate a return and receive a full refund.
  • Warranty: Brooklyn Bedding provides a warranty on their mattresses, demonstrating their confidence in the quality and durability of their products. The specific warranty terms may vary depending on the mattress model, but typically, their mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty. This warranty covers manufacturing defects and abnormalities in the materials or workmanship.

It’s important to note that policies and terms can evolve over time, so it’s always recommended to visit Brooklyn Bedding’s official website or contact their customer support for the most up-to-date and detailed information regarding their shipping, delivery, risk-free trial, and warranty policies.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  1. Those who prefer firm and supportive sleep surface
  2. It’s memory foam relieves pressure points by conforming to the body
  3. If you want a flippable mattress with 2 firmness levels
  4. Prefer CertiPUR-US certified foam
  5. Wants 10-year warranty

Cons

  1. It is an extra-firm mattress and may be too firm for some people
  2. In case you prefer a responsive mattress as it is not as responsive as some other mattresses
  3. It is not suitable for budget-friendly shoppers

Firmness

Plank by Brooklyn Bedding is specifically designed to provide a very firm sleeping surface, which sets it apart from other mattresses in the market.

One of the significant features of Plank mattress is its flippable design. It means that you can use either side of the mattress, each offering a different level of firmness. On one side, you have a firm option, which is rated at 8 on the 10-point firmness scale. This side provides a firm feel, offering a balance between support and comfort.

On the other side, you have the extra firm option, which is rated at 10 on the firmness scale. This side is significantly firmer and is intended for individuals who prefer an extremely firm sleeping surface. It offers a minimal amount of contouring and is designed to provide maximum support.

Plank mattress is constructed to provide a flat, even surface, eliminating any noticeable sinkage or contouring. It is designed to appeal to sleepers who prefer a very firm feel and those who require extra support, such as stomach or back sleepers.

It’s worth noting that the firmness levels of a mattress can be subjective and may vary depending on personal preferences and body types. It’s always recommended to try out a mattress or read customer reviews to get a better understanding of how it may feel to you before making a purchase decision.

Experience the Luxury of All-foam Mattresses: Explore Our Top-rated Mattress Reviews.

Material & Construction

Q1. What are the unique technology, design, and materials used in the construction of the Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattress?

Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattress’s construction features six different layers; Glacitotex™ cooling cover (optional), .75″ quilted top layer, 6″ high-density base foam, 2″ memory foam, .75″ quilted bottom layer, and Glaciotex™ cooling cover. The cooling cover is optional and if added, needs to be applied on both sides as this is a flippable mattress.

Glaciotex™ Cooling Cover: This optional layer can be used as a cooling cover on either side of the mattress. GlacioTex™ cooling cover is made with a special fabric that contains cooling fibers. These fibers help to pull heat away from the body and keep the skin cool. The cover also has a water-resistant layer that helps to protect the mattress from spills and stains.

The ideal skin temperature for sleep is around 88 degrees Fahrenheit. When the body gets too hot, it can be hard to fall and stay asleep. GlacioTex™ cooling cover helps to keep the body cool and helps you to sleep comfortably all night long.

Here are some of the benefits of using a GlacioTex™ cooling cover:

  • Helps to keep the body cool
  • Promotes better sleep
  • Reduces sweating
  • Prevents the growth of bacteria and mold
  • Protects the mattress from spills and stains

If you are a hot sleeper, the GlacioTex™ cooling cover may be a good option for you. It can help you to sleep more comfortably and get a better night’s sleep.

Quilted top layer: A .75” thin quilted top layer of the Brooklyn Plank Extra Firm mattress is patterned with continuous stitching. This stitching helps to create a flat, smooth sleeping surface that provides zero loft. The zero loft ensures that the mattress is ultra-firm and provides excellent support for pressure points.

The continuous stitching also helps to prevent the mattress from sagging over time. The stitching helps to keep the foam layers in place and prevents them from shifting. This helps to ensure that the mattress maintains its firmness and support for many years to come.

The quilted bottom layer is also made with a breathable fabric. This fabric helps to keep the mattress cool and comfortable. The combination of the zero loft and the breathable fabric makes Brooklyn Plank Extra Firm mattress a good choice for people who sleep hot.

Base Layer: This layer consists of 6” high-density foam. It is made with a higher concentration of polyurethane, which makes it more durable and resistant to sagging. This is important because the base foam is the foundation of the mattress and supports the weight of the sleeper. A high-density base foam helps to ensure that the mattress will last for many years without sagging or losing its support.

Premium Memory foam: Underneath the base layer rests 2” premium memory foam that adds deep compression and support.

Quilted Bottom Layer: Everything rests on a thin .75” quilted bottom layer. It is a quilted layer with tack-and-jump stitching. This stitching helps to create a flat, smooth sleeping surface that provides minimal loft. The minimal loft ensures that the mattress is firm and provides excellent support for pressure points.

The tack-and-jump stitching also helps to prevent the mattress from sagging over time. The stitching helps to keep the foam layers in place and prevents them from shifting. This helps to ensure that the mattress maintains its firmness and support for many years to come.

The quilted top layer is also made with a breathable fabric. This fabric helps to keep the mattress cool and comfortable. The combination of the minimal loft and the breathable fabric makes  Brooklyn Plank Firm mattress a good choice for people who sleep hot.

Rating

(4.13/5)
Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattress
Materials & Construction (1=Least, 5=Best) (4.25/5)
Repositioning (1=Least, 5=Best) (4.00/5)
Comfort (1=Least, 5=Best) (4.25/5)
Cooling (1=Least, 5=Best) (4.00/5)
Motion Isolation (1=Least, 5=Best) (4.25/5)
Edge Support (1=Least, 5=Best) (4.00/5)
Overall Rating 4.13/5
Rating Scale: 1 = Average, 2 = Good, 3 = Very Good, 4 = Excellent, 5 = Winner

Repositioning

(4.00/5)

Q1. How would you rate Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattress from a repositioning & responsiveness perspective? 

Repositioning refers to how easy or difficult it is to change positions on a mattress. A mattress with good repositioning allows you to move and adjust your body without feeling stuck or restricted. Responsiveness, on the other hand, refers to how quickly a mattress adapts to changes in pressure and movement.

Repositioning: Brooklyn Plank mattress, with its firm feel, mitigates the common issue of feeling trapped in the bed that is occasionally associated with all-foam models. This feature can make it easier for sleepers to change positions on the Plank.

The Plank is intentionally designed to provide a firm and even sleeping surface, resulting in minimal contouring. Unlike mattresses that incorporate memory foam, which tends to retain the sleeper’s body impression and respond slowly to changes in pressure, the Plank is unlikely to retain noticeable impressions. This characteristic enables most sleepers to move across the mattress surface and change positions without hindrance.

In short, Plank’s firm feel reduces the sensation of being trapped in the mattress, allowing for easier repositioning and unrestricted movement during sleep.

Responsiveness: The Plank Firm Mattress is very responsive, which means that it springs back quickly when you move. This can be a good thing or a bad thing, depending on your preferences. If you like to sink into your mattress and don’t like to feel like you’re sleeping on top of it, Plank Firm may not be the right mattress for you. However, if you’re looking for a mattress that will provide good spinal alignment and support, Plank Firm is a good option.

Comfort, Back Support, Pressure Relief

(4.25/5)

Q2. How would you rate Brooklyn Plank Mattress for providing comfort and pressure relief to sleepers? 

Sleepers who like to sink into their mattress or who tend to toss and turn a lot at night may not find Brooklyn Plank Firm an ideal mattress choice. However, it is a suitable option for people looking for a mattress offering good spinal alignment and back support. It’s also very responsive, so it’s easy to move around on.

Here is a detailed look at how Brooklyn Plank Mattress offers comfort and pressure relief to sleepers:

Comfort: Brooklyn Plank Mattress is not the most comfortable mattress for everyone. It’s very firm, so it can feel uncomfortable for people who like to sink into their mattresses or who have pressure points in their hips or shoulders. But as mentioned earlier, this mattress is a good choice for those seeking spinal alignment and support.

While many foam mattresses are designed to closely contour the sleeper’s body and alleviate pressure points, Plank mattress takes a different approach by providing a stable and even sleeping surface. As a result, Plank does not offer the same level of pressure relief as many other all-foam models.

Due to its limited contouring, pressure points can potentially develop around the hips and shoulders of the sleeper on the Plank mattress.

However, it’s worth noting that the firm side of the mattress offers slightly more contouring, making it a relatively better option for side sleepers and individuals who are concerned about pressure points. The extra-firm side, on the other hand, is one of the firmest sleep surfaces available and is unlikely to provide significant pressure relief.

It’s important to consider your personal preferences and specific needs when choosing a mattress, especially regarding pressure relief. While Plank may not excel in relieving pressure points like some all-foam models, it may still be suitable for those who prioritize a stable and firm sleeping surface.

Cooling & Temperature Control

(4.00/5)

Q3. How would you rate the cooling and overall temperature control characteristics of Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattress?

Brooklyn Plank mattress offers a firm and extra firm feel and includes an optional cooling top panel, making it a cooler sleeping option compared to many other all-foam models.

Due to its firmer nature, Plank allows sleepers to experience less sinkage into the mattress. This promotes better airflow around the body, aiding in heat dissipation. Additionally, each side of the Plank features a lower-density top layer, which enhances air circulation within the mattress.

While both the firm and extra-firm sides of the Plank provide cooler sleep compared to some mattresses, the extra-firm side has an advantage in temperature regulation. The extremely firm feel minimizes sinkage, thereby reducing heat retention.

For individuals who tend to feel hot during sleep, Plank mattress offers an optional cooling top panel. This panel incorporates a PCM (Phase Change Material) fabric that contributes to further cooling the mattress surface, helping to regulate body temperature.

Motion Isolation and Sharing a Bed

(4.25/5)

Q4. Does Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattresses provide reasonable motion isolation when sharing a bed with others?

Plank Mattress is a very firm mattress, which means that it may not be the best option for people who are easily disturbed by motion. This is because firm foams tend to transfer motion more easily than softer foams. When one partner moves or gets up during the night, the other partner may feel the vibrations across the surface of the bed. This can lead to sleep disturbances, especially for people who are light sleepers.

The firm side of the Plank Mattress may isolate motion slightly better than the extra firm side due to its softer foam. Additionally, the firm side of the mattress uses a transition layer that can dampen vibrations. However, even with these features, Plank Mattress is still a very firm mattress and may not be the best option for people who are easily disturbed by motion.

Edge Support

(4.00/5)

Q5. How would you rate the edge support of Brooklyn Plank Firm Mattresses?

Similar to many other all-foam mattresses, Plank Mattress does not have reinforced edges. This means that there might be some sinkage when sitting or sleeping near the edges of the mattress. While the edges of the Plank Mattress may not be as robust as those found in innerspring or hybrid models, the firmness of the mattress can provide a relatively more secure feeling compared to many other all-foam mattresses. This allows most sleepers to utilize the entire surface area of the mattress, including the perimeter.

Recommendation based on sleeping style

Side Sleepers:

The Plank Mattress’s firm side, rated around 8 on the firmness scale, may be firmer than what most side sleepers prefer. However, some side sleepers may still appreciate the mattress’s even support and subtle contouring. Side sleepers weighing over 130 pounds are more likely to experience contouring and pressure relief, while those weighing less than 130 pounds may not sink deeply enough for noticeable contouring, potentially leading to more pressure around the hips and shoulders.

Back Sleepers:

Back sleepers typically prefer an even surface without sagging, making the firm side of the Plank Mattress a suitable choice. Plank Mattress maintains an even plane and offers enough support to prevent excessive sinking of the hips for most back sleepers. Back sleepers weighing over 130 pounds may experience a good balance of support and cushioning, while those weighing less than 130 pounds may find it slightly too firm.

Stomach Sleepers:

The stable support provided by the firm side of the Plank Mattress makes it a great fit for most stomach sleepers. The firm side supports the midsection of stomach sleepers without allowing excessive sinking. Stomach sleepers weighing over 130 pounds are likely to find Plank Mattress particularly suitable, while those weighing less than 130 pounds will also find it supportive, although it may be firmer than normal for some individuals in this weight range.

Plank Firm – Extra Firm side:

Side Sleepers:

Most side sleepers find the extra firm side of Plank Mattress firmer than their preference. The extra firm side is exceptionally firm, offering very little contouring for the hips and shoulders, potentially leading to more pronounced pressure points. Side sleepers weighing less than 130 pounds may be especially affected, although those who enjoy an extremely firm feel might still appreciate Plank’s extra firm side.

Back Sleepers:

Many back sleepers may appreciate the even support provided by the extra firm side, although some may find it too firm. The extra firm side offers steady support, preventing excessive sinking of the hips, which can be beneficial for back pain. However, it may lack sufficient cushioning for some back sleepers due to the very firm foam used in the 1.5-inch comfort layer.

Stomach Sleepers:

The extra firm side of the Plank Mattress tends to provide the necessary support for stomach sleepers, preventing excessive sinking of the midsection. The 1.5-inch firm comfort layer and firm polyfoam core help maintain alignment and reduce the likelihood of sinkage around the midsection. However, some stomach sleepers, particularly those weighing less than 130 pounds, may find that the extra firm side lacks the desired level of cushioning.

Price

Size Price Sale Price Discount
Twin $749 $561 25%
Twin XL $849 $636 25%
Full $999 $749 25%
Queen $1332 $999 25%
Cal King $1532 $1149 25%
King $1532 $1149 25%
Get Coupons
x
Cashback from www.smartmattressbuy.com when you purchase a Brooklyn Bedding mattress
Brooklyn Bedding

- Brooklyn Bedding Offers
  • 25% Off Sitewide. Use Promo Code REFRESH25. Sale Ends 4/16/2024.

Price History

Coupons & Deals

  • 25% Off Sitewide. Use Promo Code REFRESH25. Sale Ends 4/16/2024.